Home / Best Picks / Toaster ovens

Best Toaster Ovens: Classic Convection vs Air-Fry Models

As an Amazon Associate, CrispyCounter earns from qualifying purchases. Prices checked Oct 27, 2026 (America/Chicago); they change. Launch picks are research-based until marked “Tested.”

Quick picks

Bottom line: If you already own a basket air fryer (or don’t care about air fry), buy a classic toaster oven — Breville BOV800XL when you want precision, Cuisinart TOB-40N when you want simple and cheaper. If you want one appliance to replace toaster and air fryer, jump to an air-fryer toaster oven and read our basket vs AF toaster oven comparison.

Classic toaster oven vs air-fryer toaster oven

Marketing muddies this. A classic toaster oven toasts, bakes, broils, and often uses convection. An air-fryer toaster oven adds a high-velocity air-fry mode (and usually a mesh basket) so frozen fries and wings get closer to basket-air-fryer crunch.

We already cover the basket-vs-AF-oven decision in depth here: Air fryer vs air fryer toaster oven. This page is for people shopping toaster ovens — including classic models that are not trying to be air fryers.

Best classic: Breville Smart Oven BOV800XL

The BOV800XL is the long-running “smart oven” that serious reviewers kept recommending before air-fry modes took over every SKU. Convection, element IQ-style heating logic, and enough capacity for toast-for-a-family plus small sheet-pan dinners. It is not the Air Fryer Pro (BOV900) — that’s intentional. If you want a dedicated toaster/bake oven without paying the AF-pro premium, this is the class leader.

• Street band: often around $160–$250 (Amazon’s Choice / high sales velocity at last check)
• Best for: households that toast daily and bake small trays; people who already own a basket air fryer
• Watch-outs: permanent counter footprint; learn the darkness/temp dials once and leave a note on the fridge

Best budget classic: Cuisinart TOB-40N Custom Classic

Not everyone needs Breville’s brain. The Cuisinart TOB-40N keeps dials simple: toast, bagel, bake, broil, pizza. About 7.6K ratings and a street price often around $108 at last in-stock check. It’s the honest “replace the old toaster and occasionally bake garlic bread” machine.

• Best for: renters, dorm-adjacent kitchens, backup ovens in summer heat
• Skip if: you want precise digital presets or a dedicated air-fry basket — look at Breville AF Pro instead

Best air-fryer toaster oven (existing pick)

When you want toast and serious air fry in one footprint, we still point to the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro (BOV900) — already live on our Best Picks table and in the AF comparison. Street prices often sit around $400; it’s a commitment. Don’t buy it and a large basket air fryer unless you cook for a crowd every night.

Decision tree

1. Already own a basket air fryer you like? → Classic toaster oven (Breville or Cuisinart).
2. Hate owning both a toaster and an air fryer? → AF toaster oven (BOV900 class).
3. Only toast bagels and reheat pizza? → Cuisinart TOB-40N and stop shopping.
4. Tiny counter? → Reconsider a slim 2-slice toaster + store the air fryer; toaster ovens are permanent furniture.

What we skipped

• Toshiba AC25CEW-class units — new stock was unavailable or thin (resale-heavy) on research day
• Huge dual-wall ovens that belong in a remodel, not a weeknight counter
• No-name AF toaster ovens with thin review histories

How we chose

In-stock US Amazon ASINs, review volume, and clear separation between classic convection toasters and AF-capable ovens. Research-based at launch — not hands-on tested yet.

FAQ

Can a classic toaster oven replace my air fryer?

For roasting vegetables and reheating, often yes. For maximum fry-like crunch, a basket unit or AF toaster oven usually wins. See the comparison.

Do I need convection?

Convection helps browning and evening out heat. Most “smart” toaster ovens include it; bare-bones budget models may not.

Is the BOV800XL the same as the Air Fryer Pro?

No. BOV800XL is the classic Smart Oven line. BOV900 adds air-fry-focused hardware and modes. Pick based on whether you need AF in that box.

Next reads

• Air fryer vs AF toaster oven
• Small-apartment air fryers
• All Best Picks